Who Does How Much of What by When?

How effective are you at wrapping up meetings?

Have you ever left a meeting feeling like everyone’s time was wasted? I have. And in full disclosure, I’ve led a few of those meetings myself over my leadership career.

You’re not alone if you’ve felt it, either. When Harvard Business School researchers surveyed 182 senior managers across industries, 71% said meetings are unproductive and inefficient, and 65% said meetings keep them from completing their own work (Harvard Business Review).


What turns a meeting into a time-waster?

If leading meetings is part of your job, pay attention here. These are the most common culprits I see:

  • The shared mission isn’t clearly communicated.
  • The team is disconnected, or the culture is weak and low on collaboration.
  • The energy in the room is low.
  • The leader lets someone hijack the meeting and talk too long about irrelevant matters.
  • The leader isn’t prepared.
  • The agenda isn’t thought out or isn’t shared in advance.
  • Little to no value is delivered during the meeting.

We could spend a full post on each of these. For now, though, I want to focus on one truth: the biggest opportunity for a successful meeting doesn’t happen during the meeting. It happens afterward. So what do the expectations look like, and what is the follow-up process?

That makes the biggest waste of meeting time this: people leaving without clarity on who (the person or people responsible) does how much (the quantity) of what (the task) by when (the deadline). And just as important, what will progress reporting look like along the way?


Decision points

“Begin with the end in mind” is Habit 2 in Stephen Covey’s The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People, and it forces us to make decisions. Covey also observed, “People are working harder than ever, but because they lack clarity and vision, they aren’t getting very far.” That sums up a lot of meetings I’ve sat through.

Meetings don’t happen for their own sake. They’re a gathering place to get on the same page before executing a strategy. Think of a huddle before the next play in a football game. The huddle matters, but it’s utterly meaningless if the players walk away without clarity on what to do next.

When we, as meeting leaders, know we need to establish clarity of execution by the end, we’re more likely to make decisions and act on them. Forward movement on a good decision is exponentially more effective than stalling in search of a perfect one. Why?

First, a perfect decision is unattainable. Every decision has tradeoffs, and we can always debate the pros and cons. The goal is to make a good decision, then turn it into a great one through execution and course correction along the way.

Jeff Bezos made a similar point in his 2016 letter to Amazon shareholders: “most decisions should probably be made with somewhere around 70% of the information you wish you had.” Wait for 90%, he argued, and you’re probably being slow.


Collaboration, not consensus

And second, another place I see leaders get tripped up is hesitating due to lack of consensus. Too many meetings end without direction because not everyone agreed and the leader lacked the courage to make the call.

Collaboration is the goal, not consensus. Collaborate, make room for robust dialogue and creative tension, and then make the decision. Set the expectation that everyone will bring the resources and support needed to elevate it to a great decision. In that same letter, Bezos recommended teams “use the phrase ‘disagree and commit.’ This phrase will save a lot of time.” I couldn’t agree more.

Yes, some decisions require more information gathering after the meeting. Apply the same “who does how much of what by when” to that work, and set a deadline to make the call.


Apply the process

If you’ve been in a coaching session with me or have followed this blog for a while, some of this will be review.

Over 20 years of selling, leading, and coaching leaders and sales professionals, I’ve participated in and led hundreds of meetings. Along the way, I developed a framework that adapts to any type of meeting:

  1. Preparation
  2. Energy
  3. Connection
  4. Value
  5. Commitment
  6. Expectations
  7. Persistence

It isn’t a catchy acronym, but you’ll notice it’s a palindrome: P-E-C-V-C-E-P reads the same forward and backward. Maybe that helps it stick. Let’s walk through each step. I’m confident that when you apply it, your meetings will become more effective.

Step 1: Preparation

This is what happens before the meeting, and preparation is the antidote to wasted time. Get your materials together, practice the questions you’ll ask, and anticipate the challenges. Gather the information you’ll need to share and discuss so a decision can actually be made.

  • Write down the one decision or outcome this meeting must produce. If you can’t name it, you may not need the meeting.
  • Invite only the people who own a piece of the decision or the work.
  • Send a clear agenda at least a day in advance, with any pre-reads, so others can prepare too.

Step 2: Energy

Read the room. Energy doesn’t always mean charisma and excitement. Those fit some situations, but other times you’re dealing with more somber topics. Either way, always bring GRACE: gratitude, reason, adaptability, confidence, and empathy.

Pro tip: Life happens, and we often walk in with a lot on our minds. Before any meeting, pause, take a deep breath, and remind yourself of your mission and how you’ll enroll others to work as a team toward it. Remember that you’re leading human beings with emotions, each going through something in their personal lives.

  • Start on time. It signals respect and sets the pace.
  • Match your tone to the topic, and adjust as you watch body language.

Step 3: Connection

Preparation and the right energy set you up to focus on building connection and likability with your people. They need to feel that you care about them before they’ll care about serving the team and the mission. Asking great questions, listening, and genuinely caring about the answers is a great start.

  • Use the first few minutes, or the time when people arrive early, for a quick personal check-in. Early arrivals should be part of the standard, so the meeting can start on time.
  • Draw out the quieter voices by name. The best idea in the room isn’t always the loudest one.

Step 4: Value

Bring the content: the data, materials, talking points, updates, training, and questions. Then open the floor for discussion and counterpoints. Make sure everyone has the information they need to make a good decision. The goal is clarity and confidence in the outcome.

  • Lead with what’s changed and what needs deciding, not a status recap people could have read in an email.
  • Guard the agenda. When a side topic comes up, park it and schedule it, so no one can hijack the meeting.

Step 5: Commitment

Don’t forget to ask for the agreement! Now we commit to the decision, everyone gets on board, and we determine who does how much of what by when.

Peter Drucker put it plainly: “Unless commitment is made, there are only promises and hopes… but no plans.”

Before anyone leaves, capture each commitment out loud and in writing:

  • Name one owner per task. Shared ownership often means no ownership.
  • Have each owner repeat their commitment back. You’ll catch misunderstandings before they cost you a week.

Step 6: Expectations

Set the stage for what happens next, every single time. This critical, often-overlooked step belongs right after the commitment is made. Answer these questions before the meeting ends:

  • What level of quality is expected?
  • What level of service?
  • What does progress reporting look like, and how often?
  • Who else needs to know about this decision, and who will tell them?

Then send a short recap within 24 hours with the decisions, the commitments table, and the reporting plan.

Step 7: Persistence

Following up with the people performing post-meeting tasks is logical, and it’s professional as long as you handle it professionally. You make the call on how often is too much. Micromanagement isn’t the goal, but inspecting what we expect is.

  • Put follow-up dates on your calendar the moment the meeting ends.
  • Open your next meeting by reviewing the last one’s commitments. Celebrate what got done, and reset what didn’t.

The huddle is not the play

A great meeting isn’t measured by how good it felt in the room. It’s measured by what gets done after everyone leaves. Prepare well, bring the right energy, connect with your people, and deliver real value. Then close strong: secure the commitment, set the expectations, and follow up with persistence.

Here’s my challenge for you this week. Before you end your next meeting, stop and ask the room one question: “Who does how much of what by when?” If no one can answer it, you aren’t done yet.

Try it, and let me know how it goes. I’d love to hear what changes when your team walks out of the huddle knowing exactly what play to run.


Sources

  • Leslie A. Perlow, Constance Noonan Hadley, and Eunice Eun, “Stop the Meeting Madness,” Harvard Business Review, July–August 2017; statistic as reported by Inc.
  • Stephen R. Covey, “Habit 2: Begin With the End in Mind,” FranklinCovey
  • Jeff Bezos, 2016 Letter to Amazon Shareholders (published April 2017)
  • Peter Drucker, as quoted in Process Excellence Network

Calling all graduates!

For a limited time, join our One To Grow On Community at a discounted rate. Get the personalized tools to master life transitions, build good habits, and kickstart your career today!

Use promo code CLASS2024 at checkout for 50% off your first three months!